May 24, 2018 Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB)
»
Item 1 - Roll Call
Item 1

»
Item 2 - General Public Comments for Items not on the Agenda
Item 2

»
Item 3 - Approval of Minutes
Item 3

»
Item 4 - Modification and approval of Agenda
Item 4

»
Item 5 - Recommended Expedited Hearing Items (To be recommended 1 week before meeting)
Item 5

»
Item 6A - Continued Items from the previous HARB meetings
Opinion of Appropriateness Don Crichlow & Assoc. – Applicant
F2017-0153 18
St. George Street LLC. – Owner
18 St. George Street
To construct new buildings between Spanish and St. George set in the character of the Spanish Colonial Architecture. (Two versions of the proposed building were provided.)
Item 6A

Opinion of Appropriateness Don Crichlow & Assoc. – Applicant
F2017-0153 18
St. George Street LLC. – Owner
18 St. George Street
To construct new buildings between Spanish and St. George set in the character of the Spanish Colonial Architecture. (Two versions of the proposed building were provided.)
»
Item 6B - Variance to the Design Standards for Entry Corridors
2018-0047
Joanna Stark – Applicant
Diocese of St. Augustine – Owner
101 San Marco Avenue
To request a variance to the sign standards for a free standing sign that exceeds the maximum size allowed in the Design Standards.
Item 6B

2018-0047
Joanna Stark – Applicant
Diocese of St. Augustine – Owner
101 San Marco Avenue
To request a variance to the sign standards for a free standing sign that exceeds the maximum size allowed in the Design Standards.
»
Item 7 - Opinion of Appropriateness
F2018-0066 56
St. George LLC – Applicant
The Monk’s Vineyard – Owner
56 St. George Street
To replace the rear canopy, the front balcony, the second story windows and doors (main façade), and the existing stucco (main façade); cover the low wall in the front with stucco; install a handrail on the rear stairs and balcony; remove the existing A/C unit and hood exhaust and replace with new equipment; remove existing windows on the southern façade and install new windows on the same elevation; and paint a portion of the front façade.
Item 7

F2018-0066 56
St. George LLC – Applicant
The Monk’s Vineyard – Owner
56 St. George Street
To replace the rear canopy, the front balcony, the second story windows and doors (main façade), and the existing stucco (main façade); cover the low wall in the front with stucco; install a handrail on the rear stairs and balcony; remove the existing A/C unit and hood exhaust and replace with new equipment; remove existing windows on the southern façade and install new windows on the same elevation; and paint a portion of the front façade.
»
Item 8 - Certificate of Appropriateness
F2018-0064
Crown Castle NG East LLC – Applicant
City of St. Augustine – Owner
NE corner of Cathedral Place and Cordova Street
To construct a 40 foot tall concrete utility pole with
an antenna and telecommunications equipment on
the current sidewalk area.
Item 8

F2018-0064
Crown Castle NG East LLC – Applicant
City of St. Augustine – Owner
NE corner of Cathedral Place and Cordova Street
To construct a 40 foot tall concrete utility pole with
an antenna and telecommunications equipment on
the current sidewalk area.
»
Item 9A - Certificate of Demolition
F2018-0060
Century 21 Property Group and Les Thomas
Architect Inc. – Applicants
Robert F. and Barbara Carberry – Owner
10 Beacon Street
To demolish a building constructed in 1956 that is
recorded on the Florida Master Site File and is not
located in a historic district.
Item 9A

F2018-0060
Century 21 Property Group and Les Thomas
Architect Inc. – Applicants
Robert F. and Barbara Carberry – Owner
10 Beacon Street
To demolish a building constructed in 1956 that is
recorded on the Florida Master Site File and is not
located in a historic district.
»
Item 9B - F2018-0061
Century 21 Property Group and Les Thomas
Architect Inc. – Applicants
Mary Ann Cramer & Ana Filomena Macedo –
Owner
155 Washington Street
To demolish a building constructed in 1930 that is
recorded on the Florida Master Site File and is a
contributing building to the Lincolnville Historic
District. (Deemed substantially damaged by the city
building official)
Item 9B

Century 21 Property Group and Les Thomas
Architect Inc. – Applicants
Mary Ann Cramer & Ana Filomena Macedo –
Owner
155 Washington Street
To demolish a building constructed in 1930 that is
recorded on the Florida Master Site File and is a
contributing building to the Lincolnville Historic
District. (Deemed substantially damaged by the city
building official)
»
Item 9C - F2018-0062
Tracy Vandusen – Applicant
Roger and Tracy Vandusen – Owner
9 Milton Street
To demolish a garage built in 1930 that is not listed
on the Florida Master Site File but that is a
contributing building in the Nelmar Terrace Historic
District
Item 9C

Tracy Vandusen – Applicant
Roger and Tracy Vandusen – Owner
9 Milton Street
To demolish a garage built in 1930 that is not listed
on the Florida Master Site File but that is a
contributing building in the Nelmar Terrace Historic
District
»
Item 9D - F2018-0065
St. Johns Law Group- Applicant
Sale Vita LLC – Owner
841 Anastasia Blvd.
To demolish a building constructed in 1930 that is
recorded on the Florida Master Site File and is not
located in a National Register Historic District.
(Deemed Substantially Damaged by the Building
Official)
Item 9D

St. Johns Law Group- Applicant
Sale Vita LLC – Owner
841 Anastasia Blvd.
To demolish a building constructed in 1930 that is
recorded on the Florida Master Site File and is not
located in a National Register Historic District.
(Deemed Substantially Damaged by the Building
Official)
»
Items 10 & 12 - 10. Other Business
a) Discussion regarding grant applications for three proposals being submitted to the
Florida Division of Historical Resources by the City of St. Augustine
b) Staff update regarding the status of the Historic Preservation Master Plan
c) Reminder of National Historic Preservation Month open house at the historic
Waterworks in Davenport Park
12. Adjournment
Items 10 & 12

a) Discussion regarding grant applications for three proposals being submitted to the
Florida Division of Historical Resources by the City of St. Augustine
b) Staff update regarding the status of the Historic Preservation Master Plan
c) Reminder of National Historic Preservation Month open house at the historic
Waterworks in Davenport Park
12. Adjournment
© 2021 Swagit Productions, LLC