Continued Items from the previous HARB meetings: Opinion of Appropriateness F2017-0036 San Marco Hotel, Inc. – Owner St. Johns Law Group/James G. Whitehouse, Esq–Applicant Continued from April 20, 2017 6 W. Castillo Drive (AKA San Marco Hotel PUD), 11 Grove Avenue, 14 W. Castillo Drive, and 19 Grove Avenue To modify a previously approved Opinion of Appropriateness for the design of new surface parking lots and associated site features to include a tunnel. This application is associated with an amendment to the Planned Unit Development.
Local Historical Landmark Designation in association with a Certificate of Demolition F2017-0048 18 St. George Street LLC – Owner Donald Crichlow & Assoc. – Applicant Continued from May 25, 2017 18 St. George Street To demolish a building constructed ca. 1888 with subsequent alterations and additions and located in the St. Augustine National Register Historic District. In addition, to evaluate the property by the Historic Architectural Review Board for designation as a local historical landmark using criteria and standards established by the National Register of Historical Places substituting importance to the City and State levels, rather than the nation as a whole.
Certificate of Appropriateness F2017-0081 The Holborn Group Inc. – Owner Hugh Holborn – Applicant Vacant Lot PID 1939500010 W. Castillo Drive To construct a one-story residential building with intersecting gable roofs, horizontal and shingle siding, and front and side porches including a fence and parking area.
Certificate of Demolition F2017-0066 St. Paul AME Church – Owner Reverend Ron Rawls – Applicant Continued from May 25, 2017 100 Martin Luther King Avenue To demolish the remainder of the Echo House building, a contributing building to the Lincolnville National Register Historic District, and constructed ca. 1926.
Certificate of Demolition F2017-0067 Dade County Holding, LLC – Owner ADCAP Construction, LLC – Applicant 24 Arenta Street To demolish a building constructed ca. 1930 and recorded on the Florida Master Site File and not located in a district.
F2017-0084 Bryson Hendricks – Owner and Applicant 204 N. Whitney Street To demolish a building constructed in 1945 that is not recorded on the Florida Master Site File and not located in a district.
Certificate of Appropriateness F2017-0083 David W. Lowther – Owner and Applicant 268 St. George Street To install solar panels on the roof. Drawings, site plan, and material specifications required for HP zoning districts were not provided.
Certificate of Demolition F2017-0085 Darnall Family LLC – Owner Brandon Gardner – Applicant 67 Osceola Street (rear building)/PID:1956700000 To demolish a building located at the rear of the property constructed ca. 1894 and contributing to the Abbott Tract National Register Historic District. Materials required for contributing buildings were not provided, including a condition assessment report.
10. Other Business a) Discussion and recommendations for the Historic Preservation Master Plan 12. Adjournment
Continued Items from the previous HARB meetings: Opinion of Appropriateness F2017-0036 San Marco Hotel, Inc. – Owner St. Johns Law Group/James G. Whitehouse, Esq–Applicant Continued from April 20, 2017 6 W. Castillo Drive (AKA San Marco Hotel PUD), 11 Grove Avenue, 14 W. Castillo Drive, and 19 Grove Avenue To modify a previously approved Opinion of Appropriateness for the design of new surface parking lots and associated site features to include a tunnel. This application is associated with an amendment to the Planned Unit Development.
Local Historical Landmark Designation in association with a Certificate of Demolition F2017-0048 18 St. George Street LLC – Owner Donald Crichlow & Assoc. – Applicant Continued from May 25, 2017 18 St. George Street To demolish a building constructed ca. 1888 with subsequent alterations and additions and located in the St. Augustine National Register Historic District. In addition, to evaluate the property by the Historic Architectural Review Board for designation as a local historical landmark using criteria and standards established by the National Register of Historical Places substituting importance to the City and State levels, rather than the nation as a whole.
Certificate of Appropriateness F2017-0081 The Holborn Group Inc. – Owner Hugh Holborn – Applicant Vacant Lot PID 1939500010 W. Castillo Drive To construct a one-story residential building with intersecting gable roofs, horizontal and shingle siding, and front and side porches including a fence and parking area.
Certificate of Demolition F2017-0066 St. Paul AME Church – Owner Reverend Ron Rawls – Applicant Continued from May 25, 2017 100 Martin Luther King Avenue To demolish the remainder of the Echo House building, a contributing building to the Lincolnville National Register Historic District, and constructed ca. 1926.
Certificate of Demolition F2017-0067 Dade County Holding, LLC – Owner ADCAP Construction, LLC – Applicant 24 Arenta Street To demolish a building constructed ca. 1930 and recorded on the Florida Master Site File and not located in a district.
F2017-0084 Bryson Hendricks – Owner and Applicant 204 N. Whitney Street To demolish a building constructed in 1945 that is not recorded on the Florida Master Site File and not located in a district.
Certificate of Appropriateness F2017-0083 David W. Lowther – Owner and Applicant 268 St. George Street To install solar panels on the roof. Drawings, site plan, and material specifications required for HP zoning districts were not provided.
Certificate of Demolition F2017-0085 Darnall Family LLC – Owner Brandon Gardner – Applicant 67 Osceola Street (rear building)/PID:1956700000 To demolish a building located at the rear of the property constructed ca. 1894 and contributing to the Abbott Tract National Register Historic District. Materials required for contributing buildings were not provided, including a condition assessment report.
10. Other Business a) Discussion and recommendations for the Historic Preservation Master Plan 12. Adjournment